-
Brennan, F., & Ireson, J. (1997).
Training phonological awareness: A study to evaluate the effects of
a program of metalinguistic games in kindergarten. Reading and Writing:
An Interdisciplinary Journal, 9, 241-263.
Description of subjects
Thirty-eight kindergarten children participated in this
study. Their average age was five years four months. The subjects attended
an American school located outside of London.
Description of methodology
Three kindergarten classrooms were involved. Two classes
consisted of the comparison groups and one class was the experimental
group. The experimental group received a training program that focused
on metalinguistic games. One of the comparison groups continued the
regular kindergarten program. The other comparison group used the Success
in Kindergarten Reading and Writing program.
- The
experimental group spent two hours every morning engaged in language
activities. Fifteen to twenty minutes of the two hours were spent on
metalinguistic games and activities. "The games followed the sequence
of activities suggested by Frost & Leonnegaard (1995) and were divided
up systematically, with the first three months spent developing phonological
awareness above the level of the phoneme" (p. 246). The training
started out focusing on listening games and games with sounds. Rhyming
games were introduced after the students mastered the listening activities.
The children progressed to sentences and word games. Syllabic intonation
patterns and multi-syllabic word activities followed the word games.
Finally, students concentrated on phonemes
- The
Success in Kindergarten Reading and Writing program is created to develop
reading and writing skills in young children. Four modules are included
in this program. This training focused on the picture/word association
module and the alphabet module. "The main purpose of the picture/word
association module is to provide opportunities for a child to volunteer
his or her words associated with a variety of pictures" (p. 247).
"The alphabet module, which is often combined with art work, introduces
the child to the written symbols of the English language and the noting
of selected sounds of letter combinations in ways which are correlated
with language development" (p. 247).
- The
second comparison group used Letterland characters to learn letter names
and sounds. Children were exposed to one new letter/sound each week.
Language activities followed the new letter/sound a week.
Summary of findings
The experimental group outperformed the two comparison
groups in phonological awareness skills. "Both the training group
and the Success in Kindergarten group scored significantly better than
the control group on the vc/cvc word reading test, the teacher assessment
of high frequency words, and on the spelling task. However the phonological
training group did not perform significantly better than the Success
in Kindergarten group" (p. 257). The authors concluded that phonological
awareness training is most successful when it is a complement to the
teaching of reading. Both the phonological awareness group and Success
in Kindergarten groups reached early phonemic spelling compared to the
control group.
|